Reuters - Land Girls Review
Reuters/Variety REVIEW/FILM: 'Land Girls' Flies High
The Land Girls (Period drama, British, color, no rating, 1:50)
By Emanuel Levy
PARK CITY, Utah (Variety) - Adding another interesting chapter to the revisionist history
of women's contribution to WWII, David Leland's "The Land Girls" pays tribute to
Britain's Women's Land Army, a unit composed of femmes who volunteered to work in the
fields as replacement for the men gone to war.
This traditional period drama is so exquisitely mounted and so splendidly acted that it
might overcome the lack of known stars in its cast and the ultra-romantic center that
occasionally gives the film an aura of soft melodrama. Centering on the actions,
feelings and foibles of 1940s women, "The Land Girls" holds special allure for
older female audiences, but pic is so enjoyable on its own terms that, with the right
marketing, Gramercy could reach a broader demographic.
In 1941, a new regiment called the Women's Land Army, or the "Land Girls," was
formed in England with the purpose of recruiting women from all walks of life to help
farms in desperate need of workers. Answering the call, three beautiful women,
representing different social backgrounds, arrive at a remote spot in rural Dorset.
Stella (Catherine McCormack) is a quiet, romantic woman, about to be married to a naval
officer named Philip (Paul Bettany). Quirky and cerebral, Ag (Rachel Weisz) is a
Cambridge graduate who wants to experience a different kind of life. Prue (Anna Friel),
the youngest, is a working-class hairdresser whose brazen wit and flirtatious manner serve
as a camouflage for her innocence.
The farm is owned by the taciturn, elderly Mr. Lawrence (Tom Georgeson), who's been
committed to the land since he purchased his farm at the end of WWI. Lawrence now
depends on the work of his loyal, submissive wife (Maureen O'Brien) and their volatile
son, Joe (Steven Mackintosh). Dreaming of becoming a fighter pilot, Joe resents the
fact that he's forced to work at the farm. In due course, Joe, as the only eligible
and handsome man around, courts and beds all three women. The women spend long days
plowing the soil, feeding livestock, milking cows, planting trees, even rat-catching.
Significantly, the more traditional domestic work was designated as off-limits to
the Land Girls, who were to be assigned male-oriented tasks. The movie shows how,
under harsh conditions, a unique camaraderie developed among the women, one that
strengthened them individually and collectively.
As writer and director, Leland is obviously attracted to strong, eccentric women,
evidenced in his debut, "Wish You Were Here," and its sequel, "Personal
Services" (which Leland wrote but did not helm). Lacking the former pic's rough
edge and the latter's bittersweet tone, "Land Girls" is more silky and sappy,
structured as an old-fashioned meller that occasionally feels like Masterpiece Theater,
not so much in its visuals as in its soothing sensibility.
At the same time, Leland doesn't repeat the error that Bruce Beresford committed in
"Paradise Road," which was also set in WWII and paid homage to female prisoners
in Japanese camps. Dealing with too many characters, Beresford couldn't find the
emotional core of the story. Here, Leland concentrates on three women, endowing each
with a distinctive personality -- and with a set of problems to handle.
Though nicely adapted to the screen, "Land Girls" still feels like a compressed
novel, with the requisite twists and turns of a richly dense story. Indeed, each
woman gets to experience sexual initiation, love, marriage, tragedy and, by war's end, an
altered destiny. Pic's second part centers on the genuine love that develops between
Stella and Joe, after he's denied service due to health problems. Nonetheless, the
film's more general themes -- love vs. duty, the power of friendship and, above all, the
role of WLA in providing new-found freedom for women living in a conservative era -- don't
get lost in the maze.
"Land Girls" illustrates beautifully how civilians were affected by the war --
specifically, the impact of big events on smalland ordinary lives and the meaning of
falling for the right guy at the wrong time. A brief epilogue reunites the main
characters years after the war.
Leland has assembled a large, attractive cast to populate his sprawling saga.
McCormack, Weisz and Friel fit seamlessly into their parts and form a beautiful
ensemble, with their acting at once disciplined and exuberant. Mackintosh, who
played the transsexual in "Different for Girls," is virtually unrecognizable
here, admirably holding his own against the female-dominated cast.
Production values are superlative across the board, especially Henry Braham's widescreen
location lensing (pic was shot in western England). Other outstanding contributions
include Nick Moore's smooth editing, Caroline Amies' evocative production design, Shuna
Harwood's unerringly accurate costumes and Brian Lock's amiably mellow score, which is
complemented by some period tunes.
Stella ................... Catherine McCormack
Ag ........................Rachel Weisz
Prue ..................... Anna Friel
Joe Lawrence ......... Steven Mackintosh
Mr. Lawrence ......... Tom Georgeson
Mrs. Lawrence ........ Maureen O'Brien
Janet ....................Lucy Akhurst
Philip ................... Paul Bettany
A Gramercy Pictures release (in U.S.) of a Polygram Filmed Entertainment presentation from
Intermedia Films with the participation of the Greenlight Fund and Channel Four Films of a
Greenpoint Film in association with West Eleven Films. Produced by Simon Relph.
Executive producer, Ruth Jackson. Co-producer, Andrew Warren.
Directed by David Leland. Screenplay, Keith Dewhurst, Leland, based on the novel by
Angela Huth. Camera (Technicolor, Panavision widescreen), Henry Braham; editor, Nick
Moore; music, Brian Lock; production design, Caroline Amies; art direction, Frank Walsh;
costume design, Shuna Harwood; sound (Dolby), Stuart Wilson; hair and makeup, Jenny
Shircore; assistant director, Nick Laws; casting, Jeremy Zimmerman. Reviewed at
Sundance Film Festival (Premieres), Jan. 20, 1998. (Also in Berlin Film Festival --
Panorama.)